The Best Defense

Was 1970’s 'Patton' really the first of the entire 'Godfather' series of movies?

I was talking about the 1943 American/British/Canadian campaign in Sicily the other day, which got me sidetracked into talking about the film Patton, which is how most Americans today know anything about that fight. Two little-known facts: The film was produced by Frank McCarthy, who had been an aide to George Marshall during World War II.

And, it was written by one Francis Ford Coppola. Given that much of the film takes place in Sicily, does that make it a kind of prequel to the Godfather series?


The Best Defense

Mission command is nice but what will make commanders actually practice it?

As I've mentioned, I was out at Fort Leavenworth last week. Among other things, I collected enough doctrine and books to give my suitcase a hernia.

In the new material there is lots of emphasis on mission command. I think it is a fine idea. What I don't understand is what incentives there are for commanders to actually practice it. I think many will give mission command lip service and then issue scads of fragmentary orders, undercutting the whole idea. We saw this in the report on the 2nd ACR's October maneuvers in Germany.  

The response I get is that it is so hard because we have a "zero defects" Army. I don't think we do. We have a micromanaging Army. If there really were no tolerance for defects, wouldn't we see more reliefs for incompetence?

Also, contrary to some stray comments, the prospect of relief does not increase micromanagement. In my book, I argue that it actually decreases it. (But to understand that, Maj. Rod, you'd have to read the book, not just the comments on Amazon about it.)