I read The Forever War over the weekend, and enjoyed it, even though I am not at all a science fiction fan. This line in particular struck me:

... the enemy was a curious organism only vaguely understood, more often the subject of cartoons than nightmares. The main effect of the war on the homefront was economic, unemotional…" (131)

Of course, in the book the enemy turns out to be not quite what the earthlings thought. By contrast, I think we have a pretty good idea of what al Qaeda is about. We are getting so accustomed to it that the bombing in Istanbul and the church massacre in Baghdad didn't particularly seem to make big news here.

Weird fiction note: I was also surprised to see that the love interest in Haldeman's book has the same given name and family name as the author's real wife. I think that is the first time I've seen that.

The novel also interested me in its representation of the passage of time. When I wrote a novel, I found handling time unexpectedly difficult. It also reminded me of Iraq in 2003-05, where I remember watching our bureau chief age before our eyes. We used to joke that an Iraq year was a like a dog year -- between the fear and stress, the horrendous climate, the hours worked, and the alcohol, you aged seven years for every one you spent there. I remember one night watching a Danish reporter have two glasses of wine before dinner, and then kill a whole bottle of vodka with her meal.

myyorgda/flickr

EXPLORE:IRAQ, MEDIA
 

LUVMY91STANG

9:14 PM ET

November 1, 2010

Aging...

is one of the aspects of going to the Middle East that isn't examined much, but you're right on the money. I suspect it's not a real big impact for those less than about 35. Youth grants a quicker recovery. For those past a certain age though, you never really recover completely. It's just so exhausting.

 

HUNTER

1:45 AM ET

November 2, 2010

Add in a side of responsibility

I watched my BN CDR go grey while we were in Bosnia (with IFOR when it was a nasty slog). I wondered what it would be like. I had three years of BN CMD, including a year in OIF. I didn't go grey, but I feel like I did.

Look at how the President changes over their terms for an example. Even Obama has gone grey in less than 2 years.

 

WALKING WOUNDED

12:15 AM ET

November 2, 2010

"I think we have a pretty good idea of what al Qaeda is about."

Perhaps, for a narrowly defined we. But I'd like to see that validated with a pop quiz.

We certainly don't have a handle on the tiny scale of the primary AQSL, vs the large scale and nature of the indirect lower case myth and cause. The one that we feed thru foreign occupations- and shrill crusades against holy books and community centers.

 

ERIC HAMMEL

3:00 AM ET

November 2, 2010

Vietnam

Tom, Joe Haldeman is a Vietnam vet. The Forever War was his way of ssettling his mind after he came back and decided his mind needed settling.

 

TOM RICKS

11:22 AM ET

November 2, 2010

Eric, let me ask you a question

I could see the Vietnam commentary in the book, but think it stands on its own as fiction set in the future.

My question for you: Do you think 'Starship Troopers' is in some ways a novel about World War II in the Pacific? In some ways I do, parallel to Haldeman and Vietnam. Given your knowledge, I'd be interested in hearing your take.

Thanks,
Tom

 

ERIC HAMMEL

3:49 PM ET

November 2, 2010

A Long, Long Time Ago

I read a lot of scifi to keep my aging brain rotting on schedule. I read all of Heinlein in my late teens and haven't been back since. I can't remember anything about it.

Heinlein was a USNA grad who served into the 1930s. He was involved in designing ships during WWII; I don't think he got overseas. Probably anything he wrote about war was influenced by what others told him (and what they didn't).

I can't imagine a combat vet writing anything about combat, even scifi combat, without referencing his experiences. And if a non-vet writes combat into scifi, it really shows if he lacks deep second-hand knowledge.

I read and enjoyed The Forever War long before I knew Haldeman is a Vietnam vert. I read it again a few years ago, and, for me, it stands the test of time.

 

Thomas E. Ricks covered the U.S. military for the Washington Post from 2000 through 2008.

Read More