Wednesday, March 10, 2010 - 12:30 PM

On a whim I watched Salvatore Guiliano the other night. I wish I had seen it before visiting Sicily. This is a terrific film, especially if you know the island, because it rings true.
It begins in the late 1940s, which is actually when Michael Corleone would have been there. But it portrays a far more complex world, where the Mafia is siding with the carbienere against the Communists and the aristocratic independents, and so on.
It struck me as what the Sicily scenes in The Godfather would be like if they had been done by the director of The Battle of Algiers. Like the latter, a lot of the scenes in this movie were filmed using the actual places where they occurred, with some of the original participants. When I went to GoogleEarth to locate the massacre at Portella di Ginestra, it offered a photo of the rocky hill in the background -- which I recognized from the film.
This isn't a terrorism film. It is more one about how most insurgencies end, and I am not sure there is a category for that. The only movies I can think of that fit that are this one and "The Wind that Shakes the Barley."
Note: Michael Cimino apparently made a movie called The Sicilian which is based on Mario Godfather Puzo's novel about Guiliano. Haven't seen it.
State Secrets: Google translate link:
"reconstructs the events surrounding the massacre at Portella della Ginestra. In particular, they highlight the inconsistencies in the official reconstruction of events"
is a decent movie about how some insurgencies end: with a messy political settlement that completely satisfies no one. Followed by a series of power plays, factional splitting and score settling, and a reduction in violence to a generally tolerable grade -- though punctuated by decades of periodic flareups that eventually die out with a whimper.
Salvatore Giuliano is a masterpiece, but it's Giuliano (as in Rudy Giuliani) not Guiliano. Don't see The Sicilian. It's very, very, very bad.
(4)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE