Wednesday, February 10, 2010 - 8:18 AM
One Best Defense reader suggested several Indian films might be part of my terrorism film festival. So we recently tried Black Friday, which is a docudrama about the March 12, 1993, bombings of Bombay that inflicted about 1,000 casualties in one day. My wife the saint walked out about 90 minutes into it, but I stuck with it and enjoyed it. It reminded me of Flight 93 -- a tight focus, no narration, no explanation, and a basic assumption that the viewers knows the context in which the film is occurring.
One caveat: I disliked how the film excused the quick use of torture by the Indian police. I especially cringed at the police officer's trite rebuttal: "Where are the human rights of the victims?" As my friend Stu Herrington might say, not only is police torture wrong, it also is counterproductive.
So, I'd recommend this film to anyone thinking about India, but concede that it probably is too difficult to follow for anyone who hasn't been there or who isn't studying the country. Bonus reason: If you are a huge fan of Slumdog Millionaire, you'll want to watch this, because Slumdog clearly was influenced by this film.
Is it a Top 10 Terrorism Film of All Time? Probably not. But definitely worth taking a look. And thanks to the thoughtful reader who suggested it. And more thanks to him, we have more Indian terrorism films in the queue.
You are welcome.
Glad you stuck with it.
For people like me who grew up in India during those blasts, this movie was different from sentimental crap (hindu boy meets muslim girl (or vice versa), sings songs, runs up against prejudice everywhere and love triumphs in the end with a death or two on either side) or macho stuff (indian lover goes into pakistan, wipes out an entire batch of villains (obviously pakistani military) and rides back over the border with his lover)
I noticed the torture used by Indian police in the movie. However, as someone who has faced the other end of a lathi stick (for a grand total of one time, while waiting to get tickets for a movie at a theater), I thought the movie was trying hard not to condone torture (which every indian movie that shows any police(wo)man worth his/her salt assumes is effective) while at the same time pandering to what viewers of these movies generally agree. (that torture, even if it is not effective at all, is therapeutic, to them).
(1)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE