Wednesday, January 20, 2010 - 1:07 PM

On a morning when Haiti was rocked by a big aftershock, my friend Bob Maguire checks in to make the argument that most of the damage in that poor country happened well before the earth started moving.
By Robert MaguireBest Defense Haiti correspondent
I am being asked repeatedly to assess the earthquake damage in Haiti. From my perspective, the earthquake has been simply the coup de grace to a city and country damaged for decades -- indeed centuries -- by human factors. As we and Haitians move forward, I think we must consider how Haiti had already been damaged. Only then, in the words of Bill Clinton, can Haiti be "built back better."
Haiti has been damaged over time by:
- Its own misrule; predatory governments, and political and economic elites who have developed and supported an apartheid-like socio-economic system that has left the vast majority excluded, poor and powerless and has concentrated wealth, power and privilege into the hands of a few.
- Those who peddle the denigration of Haiti and its people, and of its culture, be they delusional tele-evangelists or misinformed, superficial or paternalistic 'experts' who cast Haiti and its people as a 'basketcase,' a failed state, or a nation that can only survive through some form of international trusteeship -- ignoring the talents of Haitians, failing to expand opportunities, making the country increasingly vulnerable to external forces, be they strong storms or global commodity price increases of food and fuel, and pre-determining failure and neglect.
And, most of all, Haiti has been damaged by so-called development policies and programs over the past 40 years, mostly imposed upon Haiti without partnership or collaboration of Haitians from the beginning of the process, that have:
- Viewed the country simply as a nearby source of cheap labor that can assist 'investors' and Haitian business elites make money and as such have concentrated everything in Port-au-Prince, including poor people.
- Or, in the case of the 'development set,' have viewed Haiti as a place or even a laboratory where they can 'do well by doing good.' A Brazilian friend has described the greatest success of foreign aid to Haiti as enabling people to pay mortgages in Montgomery County, Maryland. The projects imposed upon Haiti over the past 40 years have not done good, though many involved with them have done well. Rather, these projects, largely unsustained once the grant money was gone, have neglected Haiti and its people, particularly in the rural areas where more than half of all Haitians still live, and have provoked unmitigated migration off the land toward the cities. We have seen not just in this earthquake, but previously in the floods in Gonaives of 2004 and 2008. The results: the high death tolls of poor people living in unsafe areas such as hillsides, ravines, flood plains, and coastal alluvial flats.
The damage had been done before mother nature and her shifting tectonic plates delivered the final, crushing blow. The results before the quake were grinding poverty, despair, and hopelessness combined with greater concentration of wealth in the hands of a few and the greater dysfunction of an entire nation. As we move forward from rescue and relief to rebuilding, let us remember that the real damage to Haiti occurred prior to the natural disaster.
Having a client once, with interest in Haiti some years ago, I did a country geo-political, and resource study along with a safe area intelligence digest type plan on his behalf. What I discovered goes even further than Bob Maguire has shared with us here and should also, not only include, but damn past and present U.S. policies toward Haiti.
However, the blame game aside, Maguire is correct that the damage was done long before an earthquake of this magnitude hit.
Incidentally, to get an idea of the ecological damage done over time in Haiti, one need only looks at high attitude imagery of the island of Hispaniola and compares the two countries that share the island - it's startling!
The earthquake in Haiti and the earthquake in the PRC in 2008, point to one thing -- substandard buildings will collapse with tragic results.
I live in the Mid-West, and I would not care to know how many buildings in the greater St Louis area will suffer the same fate as those in Haiti when a 7.0 quake hits here.
Sadly, building earthquake resistant buildings is a known technology, but construction remains one area where corruption can, and sometimes does, reign -- cutting corners, using cheap materials and outright lying about what was actually done.
Haiti is the most current example. Do not look for anything to change before the next big quake hits somewhere else.
No, actually I think the real damage to Haiti was done by the earthquake.
Look, I'm as devoted to the search for deep causes as anyone. I'm well aware that Haiti has been in bad shape for nearly all of its history, and have my own views as to whose fault this was. I'm painfully conscious of the frustrations endured by those who yearn for "imperialism without imperialists" -- governance for countries like Haiti in line with the best Western practice that nonetheless respects and builds on the vibrant, blameless and really interesting local culture, and does not seem at all to have been imposed from outside the country.
In the immediate aftermath of a natural disaster without recent precedent that reportedly has killed as many as 200,000 people in a nation of somewhere over nine million, it is both unproductive and in extraordinarily bad taste to dwell in public on any of this. At the moment, we are not even close to moving beyond rescue and relief to rebuilding; neither Haitians nor foreigners delivering assistance now could do anything about adjusting the baleful legacy left by Haiti's history if they wanted to.
I appreciate that the immediacy of e-mail and the Internet allows those with axes to grind to feel the satisfaction that comes from being able to grind them immediately when a larger than usual audience comes into view. That's a poor justification for not waiting until the dead have been buried.
(3)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE