Posted By Thomas E. Ricks Share

I love modern communications. Here is a straightforwar dnote from Lt. Joseph Somers responding to an item I had the other day about a shootout in Diyala province between Iraqi Police (IP) and Iraqi Army (IA):

I am the platoon leader responsible for this IA company.  The IA on IP "shootout" was due to large egos, not sectarian rifts.

The IA company is fairly competent. Last week we showed them how to clear rooms. A decent amount of them already knew how. One of the IA soldiers even made a correction on one of my soldiers. Today we taught them out to plot points on maps. 

They are making arrests completely autonomous from US forces. Most of the time I don't even know about the raids they conduct until days after.

Prior to this deployment I remember talking to one of my soldiers who had seen some of the bloodiest days of the surge. He told me how Iraq was un-fixable and how all the IA and IP were corrupt and not to be trusted, and how Iraq was going to unravel. Today I saw that same soldier sit down with a couple IA and train them how to read a map for two hours. I literally had to tell him to stop. Driving back to the FOB he spent the entire time talking to me about what we should train them on next week and how much he enjoyed it.

Iraq is a long way off, but even my most skeptical and jaded soldiers have seen the potential in Iraq in the three months we have been here.

Before I left that company commander today, I asked him how long it had been since he had actually been in a firefight with an insurgent group. He said it had been about 11 or 12 months. He said that he was tired of all the fighting and he was ready to move on.

I left that IA station a little more confident in the future of Iraq today.

AHMAD AL-RUBAYE/AFP/Getty Images

 

MONEYINABOX

6:29 AM ET

November 25, 2009

Excellent! A ray of light. A

Excellent! A ray of light. A healthy dose of cautious optimism every once in a while on FP is highly appreciated. Cheers Tom.

 

WALKING WOUNDED

4:47 PM ET

November 25, 2009

Lt. Somer's letter

Lt. Somer's letter offers a conclusion of 'no sectarianism'. Fair enough, friendly fire happens in any war.

But the excerpt offers little supporting information, such as the Kurd/Arab/Sunni sectarian nature of the respective forces and the community crossroads where this occurred. No reference to investigation by Iraqi or US officers. Was a friendly fire investigation undertaken, in a manner that the troops and the families of the casualties find acceptable?

US attitude towards Iraqi casualties was part of what Mr. Ricks indicted in both Fiasco and Gamble. Isn't the position of the IA unit the LT mentors compromised in the area where these casualties 'to ego' occurred?

The LT's confidence in IA progress is illustrated by their independent ops:
"Most of the time I don't even know about the raids they conduct until days after."

Lacking the LT's perspective, without accusation I ask: how do we guard against over-identification with the unit we are mentoring, selective info filtering from our terps and counterparts?

How is a local downward spiral shortstopped, IP/IA relations put back on track, after multiple fatality clash?

I appreciate this contribution in Rick's blog by a serving officer, and don't mean to make Lt. Somers a target for my skepticism and total lack of experience. He and his team have more than earned the right to their views in the critical training mission. But I would appreciate more detail and insight into real-war application of COIN technique, in this kind of serious friendly fire incident.

 

TIMBERLAND

7:16 AM ET

December 11, 2009

Timberland Boots

Womens Roll-Top Timberland Boots
$143.00 $83.00
Save: 42% off
Timberland Roll-Top Boots womenPremium, full-grain, waterproof leather for comfort, durability and abrasion resistance ; Direct-attach, seam-sealed, waterproof construction keep feet dry in any weather ; Quarter panel crafted with rich shearling leather and is unconstructed so it can be worn up or rolled down ; Durable laces with Taslan? fibers and rustproof hardware for long-lasting wear ; Inside of shoe is lined with shearling - up to the toe box which is lined with breathable fabric ; Rubber lug outsole for traction and durability ; Embossed Timberland tree logo on the side ; Steel shank provides maximum support ; Waterproof

http://www.brawbuy.com/
http://www.myjerseysky.com/
http://www.ghdprincess.com/

 

Thomas E. Ricks covered the U.S. military for the Washington Post from 2000 through 2008.

Read More