Posted By Thomas E. Ricks Share

Judith "WMD" Miller is out to prove wrong F. Scott Fitzgerald's assertion that there are no second acts in American life.

Here is her author ID on an op-ed piece in today's Los Angeles Times about how good Gitmo is:

Judith Miller is a contributing editor of City Journal, an adjunct fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a Fox News contributor.

In the past, Brits in her situation would go to work in African leper colonies. Americans, I think, simply lit out for the frontier. But then, Fox is kind of the news equivalent of a leper colony. I haven't liked them since Bill O'Reilly vigorously denounced me in the spring of 2003 for writing an article that quoted a worried American general predicting that the Iraq war could last until that summer. 

Mark Wilson/Getty Images

EXPLORE:IRAQ, MEDIA
 

CHARLIEFORD

2:43 PM ET

September 24, 2009

In the past, Japanese in her situation . . .

. . . well, you know.

Hard to say who deserves the other more, between her and Fox.

 

BILL KELLER

2:51 PM ET

September 24, 2009

Inward looking at best....

Judith obviously believes that looking at one's self provides a total perpective on all events. Gitmo is a stain that is being kept in delayed closing because it has become part of her benefactor's playbook. For the rest of the world, Gitmo is a turd, incarcerations without trial, regardless of how well she and the rest of her cabal mates try to polish it.

 

NORWEGIAN SHOOTER

2:58 PM ET

September 24, 2009

I never understood that quote

Wasn't Gatsby the archetypal second act of American life? In any case, since F. Scott's time, his assertion has been proven wrong over and over again. I still love my homeboy (fellow Saint Paulite), but it's time to put this one to bed.

However, Miss WMD has followed the advice of another Fitzgerald quip:

Never confuse a single defeat with a final defeat.

 

WARREN TERRA

3:53 PM ET

September 24, 2009

You, like almost everyone, misuse the Fitzgerald quote

I'm far from knowledgeable regarding literature, but I encountered a compelling argument someplace that, while the "no second acts in American life" quote is frequently encountered and seemingly always used to remark upon someone unexpectedly getting a second chance, Fitzgerald actually had an entirely different meaning in mind.

There is a traditional three-act structure in the theater, with which Fitzgerald was throroughly familiar. In this structure, the first act introduces the characters and setting, the second act contains character development and conflict, as I understand (see my first statement regarding my ignorance of literature). And in the third act the story is resolved, with major consequences for the main character.

For some reason, people talk about Fitzgerald's quote as if he had been speaking of vaudeville acts, rather than talking about the function performed by the middle section of a play.

 

TOM RICKS

4:02 PM ET

September 24, 2009

Well I'll be damned!

That's really interesting. I actually do know something about literature, but I didn't know that line of thought. I think you are right, and I appreciate your writing in.

One of my goals in life is to learn something every day, and I just did.

Best,
Tom

 

CHARLIEFORD

10:43 PM ET

September 24, 2009

What would . . .

. . . that mean then, by that reading? That in America, you never get to develop character or experience conflict? That makes no sense. But maybe this does:

http://www.madinpursuit.com/Journal/20040927.htm

I'm still skeptical, however.

 

GRANT

4:41 PM ET

September 24, 2009

I don't know much about

I don't know much about Fitzgerald, but I will say that 'leper colony' may be a bit too good for FOX news. The unfortunate lepers were ruined by chance and circumstance, whereas FOX seems to deliberately do whatever it can to provide an unfair and off-balance look at news.

 

Thomas E. Ricks covered the U.S. military for the Washington Post from 2000 through 2008.

Read More