The New ForeignPolicy.com
Global News : Passport : Ricks : Drezner : Walt : Rothkopf : Lynch
The Cable : The AfPak Blog : Net Effect : Shadow Govt. : Madam Secretary : The Call
Global News : Passport : Ricks : Drezner : Walt : Rothkopf : Lynch
The Cable : The AfPak Blog : Net Effect : Shadow Govt. : Madam Secretary : The Call
What they're reading at Gitmo
Tue, 09/08/2009 - 2:27pm

The three most popular books at Guantanamo's library for detainees reportedly are:
- The Harry Potter novels
- Miguel Cervantes's Don Quixote
- Barack Obama's Dreams From My Father
I don't know what this means.
Rickydavid/Flickr









Gitmo
They would love to read a recent article: "Close Gitmo, the Entire Base" http://g2mil.com/closegitmo.htm
It's About Escape
It's about escapism.
The “Harry Potter” novels are about escaping the powerlessness of childhood.
“Don Quixote” (the first modern novel and still the best work of prose fiction of all time) is about escaping the humdrum existence of a circumscribed life. The great Basque philosopher and author Miguel de Unamuno thought what the book was really about was man’s search for immortality. By the way, the recent translation by Edith Grossman is the one to read; it’s extraordinary.
“Dreams of Our Fathers” is about Barack Obama's journey from his life as the son of an absent father and a loving but unusual mother to the Presidency of the United States.
It seems to me that there's nothing unusual that prisoners, regardless of whether they're innocent or have committed the vilest crimes, would want to transcend their own bleak circumstances. All of these books would help facilitate that effort.
I'm SURE...
...the inmates have unfettered access to reading material. (snicker)
The last time I was in jail (anti-war demo... charges dropped, along with dozens of others arrested for no reason), the most popular book was "The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy", because it was damn near the only book available, except a bunch of Louis L'Amour westerns, and the Bible.
If they were really that dangerous, one would figure The Anarchists Cookbook (once a lefty read, now rights controlled by a right wing publishing house [snicker again]) would be the reading of choice.
..or maybe they need more copies of Prairie Fire and the Port Huron Statement http://www.archive.org/details/sds_papers , which, even though written in the sixties are prescient documents for the here and now:
"...We regard men as infinitely precious and possessed of unfulfilled capacities for reason, freedom, and love.
In affirming these principles we are aware of countering perhaps the dominant conceptions of man in the twentieth century: that he is a thing to be manipulated, and that he is inherently incapable of directing his own affairs.
We oppose the depersonalization that reduces human beings to the status of things -- if anything, the brutalities of the twentieth century teach that means and ends are intimately related, that vague appeals to "posterity" cannot justify the mutilations of the present.
We oppose, too, the doctrine of human incompetence because it rests essentially on the modern fact that men have been "competently" manipulated into incompetence -- we see little reason why men cannot meet with increasing skill the complexities and responsibilities of their situation, if society is organized not for minority, but for majority, participation in decision-making.
Men have unrealized potential for self-cultivation, self-direction, selfunderstanding, and creativity. It is this potential that we regard as crucial and to which we appeal, not to the human potentiality for violence, unreason, and submission to authority."
Do you think I can donate a copy to the Guantanamo concentration camp library Tom?
If not, why not?
Remember Cervantes escaped a Muslim prison...
Miguel Cervantes's Don Quixote is a very interesting choice as its author and one of the characters are men, crusaders, who have been imprisoned in North Africa upon returning from a battle of a Christian victory. Interesting juxtaposition by our Gitmo guests - after all these centuries.
Guantanamo's library for detainees
Are there more than 3 books available?