It is striking that the Taliban fighters seemed to know exactly what was going on when they attacked the American outpost in Wanat, in eastern Afghanistan last summer, in a fight that the Army's chain of command doesn't seem to want to talk about, but which some of those with knowledge of the incident have encouraged me to look into.

The enemy had a battle plan ready before the Americans came on the scene. According to the military's internal investigation that I reviewed, the company commander was asked at dinner the night before the attack if there were UAVs operating in the area -- an interesting question to hear from an Afghan local.

As the Taliban began the attack, they turned on an irrigation ditch, so the sound of rushing water would cover the noise of their footsteps and whispers. Their attack was well-coordinated, "a lot of fire all at one time," according to the company commander's statement. They got close enough to locate in the dark Claymore mines meant to defend the American position, and gutsy enough to turn around the mines. When they attacked, they first concentrated on the heavy weapons -- a big mortar, a .50 caliber machine gun and an anti-tank rocket launcher -- that could do them the most damage. And they fought close, so that it was difficult for fixed-wing aircraft to fire at them. They seemed to know they had at least 30 to 45 minutes before attack helicopters would be on the scene.

The obvious lesson: Keep in mind that the enemy is also learning and adapting, especially in Afghanistan, where guerrilla warfare is the national sport. This takes us back to the previous lesson: you probably need more soldiers than you think.

A second lesson: Get surveillance assets overhead before moving in, especially if you've been warned of an impending attack. If the weather is too bad for those aircraft to fly, consider delaying the mission.

U.S. Army/Sgt. Jeremy Clawson

EXPLORE:AFGHANISTAN, WANAT
 

ANON_ANON

3:19 AM ET

January 31, 2009

This reminds me of VN

This reminds me of VN firebase attacks. Weren't there some attacks (or at least one) that resulted in an AR 15-6?

Great, great journalism. Could this be a sequel to "Not a Good Day to Die?" (not all of them have to be Fiasco-size or -scale)?

 

RAS

12:55 PM ET

January 31, 2009

la plus ça change

Change the names and this story could be an excerpt from "Street Without Joy".

 

DRICKS

11:11 PM ET

January 31, 2009

Reminds me of ...

...the opening of your novel "A Soldier's Duty," in which a well-planned Afghan ambush overwhelms an American patrol.
Different topic: Les Carpenter has an article in today's Post on the NFL's recent shift away from using military terminology to describe football:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/01/31/AR2009013100163.html?hpid=topnews
Maybe the military and others will stop using sports terminology to describe everything too. Since when is a "game plan" better than a plan, and why should military (or business or political) effort "strike out" rather than fail?

 

KRISH

3:40 AM ET

February 2, 2009

 

WALKING WOUNDED

7:56 PM ET

February 2, 2009

Enemy order of battle...

or even a numeric strength estimate prior to the battle is notably missing from the 15-6.

Our expectation seems to be that the Taliban's historic ability to concentrate and swarm on their local rivals just provides a better target for our overwhelming indirect fire capability.

Are we misapplying a 'come and get us, so we can blast you' attitude in the Waygul? Are we efficiently killing the Nuristanis, men whose families and clans a COIN doctrine would hope to turn against a Pashtun Taliban pushing in from Kunar and Pakistan, to the East?

Was defending COP Bella and VPB Wanat 'the war we got' in Nuristan, as opposed the the one we want but can't have, two mountain ranges over, in Pakistan?

 

NYGDAN

2:50 PM ET

February 5, 2009

Fighters

Creeping up pre-dawn, turning on the irrigation ditches to screen the noise, messing with the claymores, fighting up close; these guys are determined. I've been hearing that the Afghan national army is exceedingly brave, but very undisciplined. Sounds like the enemy fighters have the whole 'don't fire til you see the whites of their eyes' rule down pat.
And just imagine how elated those guys must've been after this attack. It will probably grown in story-telling into a huge raid on an entire base. I often wonder about the 'legend/mythmaking' aspects of this war.

 

Thomas E. Ricks covered the U.S. military for the Washington Post from 2000 through 2008.

Read More