Tuesday, June 29, 2010 - 10:45 AM

No surprise, and probably the right thing to do. From what I hear he behaved correctly all last week, after the mess erupted. I hope he first takes a long and enjoyable vacation and then does something interesting like run an NGO.
Alaskan Dude / Flickr.com
Thursday, June 24, 2010 - 10:52 AM

Here is a thoughtful note an Air Force commander who has done tours in both Iraq and Afghanistan sent out to subordinates. This strikes me an act of leadership, recognizing that the moment calls for more than just lashing out at the media, and helping younger officers understand the significance of the situation, and the professional questions it raises. It was sent out before the president fired the general:
Gentlemen -- A few thoughts inspired by this article, not so much a detailed examination, but, rather, a riff:
This article isn't reality. It's reality filtered through the prism of one reporter and sharpened for maximum effect by his editors. There almost certainly is "another side" to this story...probably many more sides. However, this side is damaging to almost everyone involved.
Notice that, counter to the impression that collateral media accounts may have generated, GEN McChrystal actually isn't quoted as disparaging the President, his policies, or other senior administration officials. About the toughest things he says about anyone else are his comments about Ambassadors Holbrooke and Eikenberry who are, sort of, peers in this endeavor.
Still, in a counter-insurgency, it's important to cultivate a decent working relationship between the military and diplomatic components of the effort. That's going to be tough to re-establish here. Very tough.
Although it's difficult to be sure from the article-after all, Hastings isn't really on the inside-there doesn't appear to be much self-examination or self-criticism within GEN McChrystal's inner circle, and anyone who isn't in complete agreement with GEN McChrystal is deemed to be not just wrong but an enemy. That's not a staff, it's a cult.
Mr Wabu / Flickr.com
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 - 9:40 AM
I've noticed an interesting pattern in my e-mails over the last 24 hours regarding the question of whether McChrystal should be fired. That is, the more someone knows about the military, the more likely they are to call for his removal. Political types, by contrast, don't see what the big deal is.
I have been particularly struck by a couple of hard-right types I know who are retired senior officers. For them, this is a matter of good order and discipline. If you allow a general to bitch-slap an uncertain president, how do you keep the troops in line?
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 - 9:35 AM
1. Know who you are talking to. Reporters have track records. A good public affairs officer will know that record and provide you with articles with highlighted quotes.
2. Establish ground rules. If you have an embedded reporter, you need to say something like, anything you hear inside my tent is off the record until you check it with us. This goes triple for any event involving alcohol.
3. Reporters doing one-off profiles for magazines such as Rolling Stone and Esquire have less invested in a continuing relationship than do beat reporters covering the war for newspapers and newsmagazines. That doesn't mean you should avoid one-off reporters, but it does mean that they have no incentive to establish and maintain a relationship of trust over weeks and months of articles.
.ygor/flickr
Tuesday, June 22, 2010 - 10:09 AM

My bet is that Gen. Stanley McChrystal will be gone within a week or so. Defense Secretary Gates canned Admiral Fallon as Central Command chief in the spring of 2007 for less pointed remarks, so he will look like a hypocrite if he does less here in response to McChrystal dissing Obama, Biden, and the White House in a new article in Rolling Stone.
At any rate, it may be time for a whole new team in Afghanistan. My nomination is for Petraeus to step down an echelon and take the Afghanistan command. You could leave him nominally the Centcom chief but let his deputy, Marine Lt. Gen. John Allen, oversee Iraq, the war planning for Iran, and dealing with Pakistan and the Horn of Africa. But more likely is that Petraeus will ask for another Marine general, James Mattis, who is just finishing up at Jiffycom, and who had planned to retire later this year and head home to Walla Walla, Washington. Petraeus and Mattis long have admired each other. The irony is that Mattis has a reputation -- unfairly, I think -- for speaking a little too bluntly in public about things like killing people. I think Mattis is a terrific, thoughtful leader.
I do wonder if this mess is the result of leaving McChrystal out there too long-he has been going non-stop for several years, first in Iraq and then in Afghanistan. At any rate, his comments reflect a startling lack of discipline. He would expect more of one of his captains. We should expect more of him. I know, I've said worse about Biden. But part of my job is to comment on these things, even flippantly sometimes. Part of his job is not to.
Andreas Rentz/Getty Images